Xbox Classic Controller S-Type Wired Gamepad for Xbox S Type Console (Black and ClearBlue)

They are not as good as the original controllers but they work fine. I would say they are about 75% accurate.The material quality is good but not outstanding. The plastic is not the same high quality as the original. It feels light in your hand and thinner. I would estimate about half the weight. It's not that super cheap plastic but I'm still not sure they could handle a fall on the floor either.The buttons all work. They are not as smooth as the original and there are some rough edges around the sticks. The manufacturing quality control is not as good as one would hope.Overall not bad albeit not perfect. There is nothing remarkable that stands out. So I must give it a middle of the road rating 3/5.

Dont wate your money . Both controllers did not work. Then amazon wants me to send the crap back for a refund. Dont got time for that. Beware!!!

High hopes but have to send back. All 4 of the ones I bought have stick drift. I used my original controller just to make sure it wasn't the box or game and it worked fine so it had to be the new controller

These controllers work well. Also bought the NoaStore ones and the joystick would stick on them. These are a few dollars more but worth it. And still a bargain for an older gaming system's component imo. Tbf the game I play doesn't use the triggers or black/white bump buttons so I do not know if those controller components work.Been playing some Disney's Extreme Skate Adventure since I got it at Christmas from my brother. That was really the only game I ever wanted to play on our Xbox and we haven't been able to find ours for years. Love that game! Been playing it almost every night before bed since Christmas. Re-memorized all the songs (except Lil Romeo's which I tell it to skip). Life is good xD

Both controllers we received were broken. On one of the controllers the thumbsticks both stick really bad and one of the controllers doesn't work at all. Really annoying.

When these arrived I plugged them in straight away, and they just kept scrolling...as if the thumb sticks were just pinned to one side. Both controllers exhibited this behavior so I returned them. The feel of the product also wasn't nearly as good as the originals however that was to be expected, the non stop scrolling was definitely not expected.

Only 3 ft cableDecent quality controller but get ready to sit right in front of your tv or reposition your xbox

These controllers have a heavy feel and the buttons and analog sticks have a great feel and response to them. These are much better than any other 3rd party controller I have used in the last 10 years.