Milani Stay Put Eyeliner - After Dark (0.01 Ounce) Cruelty-Free Self-Sharpening Eye Pencil with Built-In Smudger - Line & Define Eyes with High Pigment Shades for Long-Lasting Wear

Why did you pick this product vs others?: I have use this for years because it stays in place without smudging. The color is also just right, not black-looking and not too light. Waterproof: It is truly waterproof. I use it to tightline and sometimes a little comes off in the inner corners, but overall it stays in place. I like that it does not transfer to my lower lash area like some others. Quality: This is consistently good quality and fresh. Functionality: It does what I need it to do, lasts and is easy to apply. It does not tug and is not too dry.

Best eye liner I have ever used. Soft texture, stays put all day. Easy to apply. Most waterproof stuff I tend to be overly sensitive to but not this one. Its really nice.

This is my new favorite liner. Goes on smooth and quick and lasts through the day without smudging. Excellent price too!

It's a stay put, non smearing eye pencil. I use it inside my lower lid. It has decent staying power and no sharpener is needed.

This eyeliner is a total staple for me. The shade Semi-Sweet is a beautiful deep brown that’s softer than black but still gives great definition—perfect for everyday wear. It goes on smooth and creamy, with really nice pigment, and once it sets… it stays put. I love that it doesn’t smudge or fade throughout the day, but you still have a little time to blend it out if you want a softer look using the built-in smudger. The self-sharpening twist-up is super convenient (no sharpener needed), and it’s gentle on the eyes—no tugging or dragging. Why I love it: Rich, high-pigment color Glides on easily Long-lasting without smearing Built-in smudger Whether you want a clean line or a slightly smoky eye, this eyeliner is easy, reliable, and affordable. Definitely one I keep repurchasing through subscription

This is the best eyeliner pencil I have ever used, and I've been wearing eyeliner for 40 years! It goes on smoothly (even on elderly eyelids) and stays on all day. I use baby oil to remove it. My eyes are fairly sensitive to makeup products, and this one is a game changer. Yes, the navy blue (they call it femme fatale) is twice the price of the black one, but it's a great color and very flattering, making the whites of the eyes look whiter. I also bought the black one and anticipate an equally positive experience with it, and it's about half the price of the dark blue one.

I keep repurchasing this eyeliner. It goes on smoothly and stays on all day. I use it to tight line the upper lash line and it works like a charm.

Applies very smooth and evenly. When waterlining or tightlining upper lid, it immediately transfers to lower. Lasts all day, but melts under the eye after a couple hours (I don’t apply under the eye).