Mary KayI ♥ Black Waterproof Lash Love Mascara

This is the best waterproof mascara I have found. Not clumpy and does not smudge at all in water

Use this all the time! I find that Amazon has it for a decent price. I buy this all the time.

I have used many different mascaras over the years, including some very expensive, and inexpensive. I truly believe that Mary Kay makes the best mascara for your money. This mascara will not run out in under 2 weeks, like most of the commercial mascaras you can buy in any drug store, Walmart, Target, etc. Since cancer, my eyelashes are almost colorless. But touching this mascara on the tips makes them stand out long and lovely like they were before chemo.

Pretty good, wish it gave my lashes a little more thickness. But it’s waterproof so that’s definitely the plus. It does not smear under my eyes during the day

This mascara does a little volumizing and little lengthening but it is not the mascara for lustrous thick and full lashes. It gives some minor volume and lightening but it's purpose is the waterproof aspect. This wears like iron and is a little difficult to remove but the product itself is bulletproof. No flaking, crumbling or smudging.