Butcher's Crossing (New York Review Books Classics) Paperback – January 16, 2007

John Williams' well constructed western novel is minimal in sentiment and takes an even handed approach to the struggles between man and nature. Nature is not evil in Williams' world, like Hemingway he portrays nature as a neutral non-caring force that supports humanity as well as destroys humanity. In this regard, the novel could be compared to the more mythic Moby Dick by Herman Melville. Williams is careful to show that mankind may master many skills when dealing with nature but that a slip or mistake can have fatal non-forgiving consequences. This is an American novel, it speaks of the American national experience in realistic non-romantic passages that take the reader deep into the heart of the North American continent's heart.Williams' writing style is highly organized, there are no tangents or extra flourishes or unnecessary descriptions. Like William James and Nabokov, the story is as tight as a well constructed brick wall, facts and descriptions and experiences all are the precise building blocks for a novel with not a word out of place. I can imagine this novel would be appropriate for a college course on creative writing as an example of a novel that gets to the point, tells the tale, does not digress, makes its points and moves on. The novel is written in three sections and each section is further divided into short chapters. This structure gives the impression that the basic armature and direction of the entire novel was outlined with precision before the first paragraph was written. This is not a criticism; it is an observation that this novel's structure is strong but evident.The great exploration and exploitation of the American west in the 1800s is certainly part of the American myth. The beauty of this novel is that it explores the many themes of exploration and ruthless exploitation of the natural resources in a purely descriptive neutral voice. The great white whale in this novel is the vast power of snow storms in the Rocky Mountains and the untamed roaring rivers and the dry forbidding deserts. Those that hunt the whales in Moby Dick may encounter the great white whale. In Williams' world, those that hunt the buffalo may encounter the consequences of the natural world, the winter in the Rockies.The novel is written from the perspective of a neutral all-seeing narrator but the experiences of young Andrews, a Harvard drop-out, form the journey on which the novel is constructed. Andrews encounters the sage in the person of McDonald, a man who deals with buffalo hide blankets for the European market. Andrews becomes a party to a hunting expedition, which he finances through a small inheritance, with a fascinating charter, Miller, who exemplifies competency and survival instinct in the wild. They are joined by Charley Hoge, a one-armed, camp-cook, wagon driver who seeks protection for a Bible that he can not understand. They are also joined by a wild buffalo skinner, Schneider, a man uncomfortable in the wild and just as uncomfortable among his fellow man.The character of Miller is central to the novel. He is a skilled hunter and very knowledgeable of the wild and survival. He is careful and a leader. He manages and distributes resources, is fair, and controls controversy. The novel however puts Miller to the test for it is Miller's temptation for excess and his pride that put the entire expedition into peril. We witness the fall of the hero here for Williams gradually, chapter after chapter, reveals to us Miller's considerable strengths and abilities, and then as the novel comes to a peak, we now see how the fatal flaws of the hero result in the conditions that bring him down. When the hero is a leader of a tribe, the fatal flaws may bring down the entire tribe. Miller is not the enigmatic Captain Ahab. He is far more present as a fleshy muscular problem-solving pack leader that Ahab. He is more akin to a realistically drawn Ulysses, constantly called upon to offer the solutions that insure survival of the hunting pack. Miller exemplifies the limitations of human cunning and willpower. Some may think that nature seeks revenge against Miller for his excessive slaughter of the buffalo. But Williams' novel presents this peril not as the revenge of a personalized nature but as the simple consequences of excessive human obsession and pride. Williams carefully and beautifully describes the grandeur of nature but he never romanticizes and he never personifies nature. A careful reader will appreciate the considerable control William displays throughout the novel but especially in his resistance to describing nature in any other than natural, realistic, neutral prose.William Andrews, who drops out of Harvard after his third year, seeks the challenge of the west. It is to Williams' credit that Andrews is not a brainless romantic and that he is a fast learning in a world where fast learning is necessary for survival. There is a young pretty prostitute, Francine, and William Andrew's encounters with her before the hunt and after the hunt are testimony to the changes that have been wrought in his personality due to the experiences he had in the winter storms.The character of Charley Hoge is more than a side-kick, for Charley has been touched by nature when he hand froze in a previous expedition and had to be amputated by Miller in the wild. Charley now carries an old Bible which he reads often but understands less. For Charley, the Bible is a talisman against the consequences of nature.Comparisons may be made with Cormac McCarthy's novels but there is an essential distinction. McCarthy sees the evil human being as being more akin to the unfeeling force of nature than to his fellowman. Thus in McCarthy's novels there is often violence of man against man in epic battles not unlike Williams' description of the battle with winder in Butcher's Crossing.This book is exceptional and deserves a wide readership. It is the type of Western novel that is exemplary American literature.

This Western is the action-packed tale of a young Harvard student who goes out West on a quest to find himself and ends up in a dangerous buffalo hunt. The book does not include the same memorably beautiful writing that the same author had in "Stoner" or, to a lesser degree, "Augustus". However, it is a fast paced and enjoyable read.I deduct one star because the book is somewhat predictable -- a feature of the genre.

Butcher's Crossing ranks with the best western novels of all time. It is less than 300 pages but plenty happens. Williams wastes no words. Readers looking for high adventure may be disappointed but this is great literature.

"Young people... you always think there's something to find out. Well, there's nothing... Then you know you could of had the world, because you're the only one that knows the secret; only then it's too late. You're too old."Sometimes social media can ruin the experience of a good novel. Had I not seen fellow book lovers rave about "the best Western ever" on Bookstagram, I daresay I would have enjoyed the experience of BUTCHER'S CROSSING more, without the weight of all these raised expectations.(And I don't mean to offend, but I think if we're ranking Westerns, John Williams' fellow Texan, Larry McMurtry, and his epic LONESOME DOVE surely takes first prize.)Don't get me wrong. BUTCHER'S CROSSING is good! How can it not be?! It's by John Williams, who is incapable of writing anything bad! His STONER was life-changing, his AUGUSTUS something I need to re-read because I don't think I was mature enough for it the first time round.The appeal of Williams is how he seems to be a different author in each novel. He is not bound by genre, because he merely uses the expected trappings to set forth his own very American, very 20th century world view: a unique blend of anti-romantic, no-BS, no-time-to-waste style all his own.The world is crap, we can imagine Williams saying, and sometimes we're dealt a crappy hand in Life. But a man's gotta have faith in something, and it's better to do SOMETHING than whine and do nothing. In an interview, Williams said "You've got to keep the faith. The important thing is to keep the tradition going, because the tradition is civilization." And while he may have been referring to STONER in this particular interview, I think this theme is very present in BUTCHER'S CROSSING as well.How, in the face of the wild West and the utter cruelty of Nature, is a man meant to hold on to civilized values?We have our protagonist, a civilized Harvard college drop out, who could not find meaning in books and cities and looked for it by going West, where he's roped into a dangerous dream: looking for an elusive herd of buffalo, to make a quick fortune.Part adventure story, part parable about the dangers of capitalist greed, BUTCHER'S CROSSING is a quick read but will last long in memory. Stripped of social status markers, alone in the wild, would we move through the world as confidently? Do we even dare venture out of the comforts of our familiar haunts? Williams' novel shows the pain and the danger, but also a different kind of reward that money can never buy.I just found out that the book was turned into a movie by Nicolas Cage last month, and now I'm excited to see if the film lives up to the book!