Well People Fresh Lines Liquid Eyeliner, Longwear Liquid Eyeliner For Precise Lines, Hydrating & Smudge-resistant Formula, Vegan & Cruelty-free, Black

Love the ease of application, great color.

This eyeliner goes on super smooth, dries quickly, and is really easy to use. I love that it’s all non-toxic and made with clean ingredients! Big win in my book. It doesn't smudge easily, has never caused any irritation, and still comes off well with makeup remover. If anything, it could be a little cheaper for the size, but honestly it’s lasted me a long time, so I can’t complain too much. Overall, I’m all about it!

Love this eyeliner, it’s clean and goes on easily, no issues with it smudging. I would give 5 stars except for the applicator. The entire applicator has liquid liner on it so it gets on anything it touches when applying: it gets on my eyelashes, my skin if it touches etc, so can be messy. If the applicator could be made to only have liquid on the tip, it would be the best on the market!

I like the way the liner looks on and it does last. I love that it's clean and cruelty free, but the wand itself is hard to work with because it's so short.

OK, I should probably work for this company cause I swear by them for everything. I use their concealer, their blush, their eyebrow eyeliner mascara foundation. But this eyeliner is great. Obviously if you’re going to use natural products, you have to understand they’re not gonna hold up as long as something with a chemical would. So this is great if you’re trying to have clean products around your eyes, which everyone should. it goes on thin it’s not messy. It holds up for me all day and I have kids and running around. If I worked to the beach, it’s 100% gonna come off but just know what you’re getting into when you buy natural make up, but this hands-down is the best company.

I had high hopes, but when i first tried it theres no ink so it came out patchy.

I enjoy this eyeliner because it does not make my eyes itch, and the brush is thin enough to make very precise lines. It's hard to find an eyeliner that's made out of organic products and does not cause an allergic reaction on my skin. I so glad that I invested in this purchase because it was totally worth it!

Never again...after five years of adopting liquid eyeliner to my routine, I decided to change course and find a "clean" liner. This is not the one, and I would even give zero stars if that were possible. 1) TINY. The box is double the size, but the length of the item is slightly longer than my thumb. 2) Uncomfortable tip - The tip seems to most similar to felt ones but is inflexible. It also takes me a lot of swipes and to get a full line on my eyelid compared to other brands (diluted liquid.) 3) The Dealbreaker - SMUDGY. I have used at least three other liner brands faithfully but never have I ever encountered one that will literally never fully dry. It smudges equally after 30 minutes vs. a whole day. Not worth the price AT ALL. I will be seeking other clean liner options.