Studio10 Longwear Smudge Proof Kajal Eyeliner Pencil (Mocha - Medium-to-Dark Brown) 3-in-1 Eye Liner Brightener and Eyeshadow Soft Creamy Eye Pencil Used by Professional Makeup Artists

As I am 64 I was looking for a softer option in eyeliner than the liquid ones provide. This is an excellent alternative, gives a softer look, is easy to apply and stays on all day long. It also has the advantage that the pencil can be sharpened.

Black eyeliner can look a little harsh if you're more mature. Studio 10's I-Lift Longwear Eyeliner comes in a range of softer tones, including the Pewter version I got. The dual-ended pencil - highly pigmented and smudge proof - comprises one end in pewter grey, the other in a light cream shade that's perfect for highlighing the inner corner of brows or below the browline. I wasn't keen on the fact that the branded card box it arrives in and the pencil itself are both unsealed and the tiny white print on the light gold ground of the pack is super-difficult to read. But if you're looking for an eye pencil that's fairly subtle yet with a creamy consistency that's easy to apply, this could fit the bill. With a matte finish and highly pigmented, it's waterproof. And it's 3-in-1. You can experiment and use it how best suits you. I like it as a matte eyeshadow - but the choice is yours. However you use it, it should last until you want to remove it and it's easy to take off. Made in Germany, this is free from parabens and, once opened, should be used within 24 months.

I love this eye liner it’s my go to but was very disappointed when it snapped in half whilst I was sharpening it. Have had a few before which have been fine but this one clearly had an issue!

Like it a lot as a product but I used it once a day for about 2 weeks and then it was blunt. Too expensive for me! :(

I have sensitive eyes so have to careful what I use this has been fine I have had no problems I ordered the brown it stays put no smudging would buy again

The eyeliner is great. It glides onto the eyelid beautifully and stays there. Expensive but worth every penny - I thought. All great until it had to be sharpened. Often a sharpener is incorporated into the pencil, especially the more expensive ones. It was then that I discovered that the outside of the pencil is much too strong to sharpen and eventually the insides fell out. Really feel a bit ripped off. Disappointing.

Love this, it’s really smooth, easy to use. And it does stay on

Studio 10 l-Lift Longwear Eyeliner - High Pigment, Smudge Proof, 3-in-1 Eyeliner Pencil - 3-in-1 Liner, Brightener & Shadow Eye Pencil (Shade - Pewter) is a very good eyeliner which has the added advantage of having a highlighter which is also good for creating different looks which I personally like. The fact you get two products within one does explain the price asked and therefore for me I found this to be of excellent value and one which is a pleasure to apply. Happy to recommend.