MAYBELLINE New York Tattoo Studio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil, Glide on Smooth Gel Pigments with 36 Hour Wear, Waterproof Rose Quartz 0.04 oz

First off I will say, you will need a makeup remover balm (I use E.L.F.) or that Micellar water to remove this eyeliner. Just using only a cleanser-makeup remover (I use CeraVe) will not get the eyeliner off completely. I use the ELF balm & then the CeraVe cleanser-makeup remover. If you use only the cleanser, you’ll be wiping all day. Raccoon eyes.Now onto my review:I purchased the Aurora Flip, Rich Amethyst & Bold Brown. I have brown eyes; I was hoping the Rich Amethyst would be darker like a plum but to me it’s bright like a burgundy. It made it appear as tho my eyelids were bleeding, like you see in the movies. That reddish pinkish tint.Aurora Flip, absolutely love this color. However, the glittery sparkly does “fall” & goes under my eyes, falls onto my cheeks. So I see that annoying sparkle spot on my cheek constantly. But unless I can find a similar eyeliner to this color, I will still repurchase.Bold brown, LOVE. LOVE. LOVE. No raccoon eyes. No smudging. Altho when I put it on, I do have to be careful not to get that small speck of liner on my contacts.As I said, just use that Micellar Water or Makeup Balm remover to get the eyeliner off. Using only a cleanser will not work.

I bought 3 colors: Rose Quartz, Bronze glitz, and Rich Amethyst. I really love these long wearing eyeliners. The rose is a bit more of a soft shimmer champagne (doesn’t really have pink undertones if you ask me), the gold is a nice metallic (doesn’t have orange or yellow under tones, and the purple is more of a matte (with more violet-magenta undertones). I am sporting all 3 colors in the pic of my eye along with Clinique’s Beach Plum eyeshadow duo. I have had no problem with the eyeliner falling, melting, casting, etc. like others have mentioned with the black color.

Creamy and easy to apply. Stays on after it dries. A little big with the tip.

So far I'm happy with the eyeliner. It doesn't last fully all day, but it does pretty good for the most part. You may have to reapply once but overall I'd say it's fairly long lasting. I use regular makeup wipes to remove it. They work okay but take a little more effort because of being waterproof. It can bleed out of the corners but is an easy fix. As far as sharpening goes, several people said they had trouble sharpening it. Others said they bought a special type of sharpener. I used a $1 sharpener from Walmart and I had no trouble at all. Just have to use it properly and you shouldn't have any problems. Overall, I would purchase the eyeliner again.

This is my favorite eyeliner. I use it on my waterline and stays all day. I have bought very expensive brands in the past and wasted alot of money. One day I saw this in Walmart and gave it a try. If you go to the store, make sure it's this tatoo.

Love the product but it lasted only 3 months using it only once a week. I found no way to extend the tip.

I'm very pleased with this eyeliner. It's super pigmented, doesn't smudge and glides on smoothly. I normally use liquid eyeliner because pencils fade so quickly but this has staying power! And you can't beat the price! Highly Recommend

I like this eye liner. It is soft and easy to put on. Doesn't irritate my eyes.