Pencil Eyeliner, ColorStay 2-in-1 Eye Makeup,Waterproof, Longwearing with Smudge Brush, Angled Kajal Eyeliner, 101 Onyx, 0.01 Oz

Went well beyond my expectations, you must not use too much pressure at all and only use a little bit a time to avoid breakage. Next I didn't expect the Evergreen to be so nice but this one really complimented my eyes and I don't usually use greens. I mistook Evergreen for black, but was pleasantly surprised by the texture, color, and quality. I really recommend, it also lasts a long time I swatched it on my leg and it faded but never went away till I wash it off on day 2 in the evening.

As a more mature woman, I want to make sure my eyeliner doesn't look tatoo'd (must blend edges!) This liner is easy to apply, doesn't pull on my skin. I like the brush to blend, color does not bleed into my eye creases. Caps are not tight fitting, already lost the brush cap (And I want to be sure the other cap stays on for fear that the eyeliner will dry out). Otherwise the eyeliner itself is one of my favorite!

I like this better than any liquid liner or pencil I have used. It goes on very smoothly and (I think) looks better than harsh color liquid. I hold it one direction for one eye and the other direction for the other eye. It can make a thinner line under the lower lashes. The smudge works for me better on the under eye than the lid. I can't seem to get to smudge between my eyelashes so I have to put some on under the upper lid and then smudge upward. I can wipe away what I don't want with a Q-tip. Stays on all day. Comes off with waterproof makeup remover. I use Fig, which is a nice deep brown. Doesn't last a long time. Have to replace often. But got it at a very good price from this seller.

Too expensive! Works very well, however, the liner breaks way too easily. Don’t be deceived by the size of the liner holder, there’s not much inside. I’ve liked and used this liner for a few years, but as the price has increased it’s way too expensive for the amount of liner you get!

I'm extremely pleased with this. I am a makeup junkie who buys all sorts of stuff even if I dont need it. This was another of those purchases, but unlike the others which I play with a couple times and then forget about, this has become my go to liner for when I need to have a perfect looking eye in a few seconds. It goes on smooth and even, and the angled tip makes the perfect line, not too thick or thin. Graphite is the perfect dark grey that will complement any eye color, I imagine (mine are dark brown) and eye shadow. And the price? Cant beat it!

I have been using eyeliner for decades! This is the easiest and longest lasting eyeliner EVER! The shape makes so much sense, the flow is great, not needing to be "sharpened" or changing shape is wonderful! Covers down to the lash line, Lasts all day, and yet is easy to remove! The price is perfect too. I'm excited to purchase again.

This liner transferred horribly on me and is not good for doing winged liner like it says. It goes on well but it moved all over even with primer. Won't be buying again and want my money back.

This review is actually for the Onyx Revlon ColorStay eyeliner. I am 67 now and all the articles about women over 60. say in big letters, do not wear black eyeliner. I love black eyeliner and if you really want your eyes to show up - use a black eyeliner, but make sure it's waterproof to avoid raccoon eyes. I used a matte beige color on the lid with a bronze color in the crease and lined my lower inner lid and on the top a little thicker liner above the lashes. Yes, I know I'm not going anywhere but I still have to put makeup on most days just for me. I did use an eyeshadow primer. I must say that my makeup looked great all day and my eyes really popped. I also wore a red matte lipstick. I hope you enjoy it as much as I do. Now I'll caution you not to twist up more that a sliver of the eyeliner at a time or it will break off. I also find that the brush on the other end does a great job of bringing the eyeliner down to the inside corner of the eye without it being too too much.