Magnolia Bakery Confetti Banana Pudding Cookies

Fresh baked goods. Was giving them as sweet treat gifts!; so I did have one myself but everyone enjoyed them.

Are very soft n quite tasty also filling liked they’re individually wrapped as well

I never write reviews but I had to for these cookies. They are not good at all. They are dry AF; nothing “soft baked” as described, and the banana flavor tastes like cheap artificial flavoring. It’s not worth the money even at a discount. Come on Magnolia’s, you can do better especially if you’re charging what you’re charging for these non-edible cookies.

very dry ,didn't taste banana

These cookies arrived in good condition and were delicious.

The Magnolia Bakery Confetti Banana Pudding Cookies with White Chocolate Chips is clearly a designer brand that is meant to be marketed to those with more expensive pallets. Pretty sure that isn't me.Out of the box, you get three boxes with four packages of one cookie in each box. The texture of the cookie is soft, but at the same time somewhat dry (which seems odd since "pudding" is in the title). The smell and initial bite SCREAM banana bread which would actually be very appetizing to me. However, the initial taste is soon replaced with a chemically after taste. Maybe its just me, but the confetti topping and white chocolate chips didn't help - they just seemed like an odd flavor combination with the banana.Finally the cost of the cookie was EXHORBITANT - $2.33 per cookie. I mean for something that expensive (and I could buy a whole package of Nutter Butters for $6 and be in hog heaven), the cookie better be lip-smacking good and they aren't even close. TBH giving the product 2 star is generous and I'm only doing it because my daughter (who has an iron stomach, hasn't seen any junk feed that she doesn't like, and is a super accurate barometer of what's "good") ate 9 of the 12 cookies.

I don't usually buy premade cookies. I would much rather make my own. They just taste better and are usually much friendlier on my wallet. The only kinds I buy are the ones that I just can't duplicate at home. I'm going to do some experimenting in the kitchen, but I think these may fall into that category.These are made with real butter and high quality white chocolate chips. It's right there in the ingredient list, but you don't need to read the ingredients to know that. You can tell by the taste. The confetti sprinkles add a little crunch and texture to what would otherwise be a very soft cookie. It's a nice addition.I agree with other reviewers that there may be just a little too much banana flavor. Maybe too much sweetness, too. It is a bit overwhelming. Can't really imagine eating more than one of these in a sitting.These are pricey, but they are made from quality ingredients and the cookies are pretty big. I wouldn't call these a grocery staple, but if you're looking to indulge a little, or maybe you're feeling nostalgic for Magnolia Bakery goodies, these are a good treat.

When this arrived, we opened it up almost immediately. My husband, my son, and I all had a cookie.Opening up the individually wrapped package, you definitely can smell banana! The cookie was soft and a bit crumbly. That word isn't quite right, it sounds like there is something wrong. I mean crumbly in the sense that you can easily pull a bite-sized piece off of the cookie without having to snap it or anything. I love cookies like this. If it was warmed up, it would have the sense of just coming out of the oven.My husband didn't really like it. No idea why. My adult son thought it was great, and I really liked it as well. He took a box to work, so he can have a cookie on his break. Having these packaged individually makes it easy to use that way.