Lip Liner Pencil Set - 12 Colors Waterproof Smudge Proof Matte Velvet Long Lasting Lip Liners Makeup Lipsticks

I always have problems with lip liner and eyeliner being too hard and doesn't go on this one is smooth like butter and goes on perfectly I also like the huge selection and the low low price. The colors are beautiful.

No waterproof and colors do not match

No care was taken in the fitting of the lids on these pencils. It's bizarre. The 12 pencils are in a box, but I mean, they would literally HAVE to be, and have to always stay in the box, because the lids instantly fall off from looseness the second you try and remove them from the box. It's a shame because it's a GREAT collection!

I just received these liners today and are happy to have such a variety of colors. I own a lot of lipsticks that I never wear and I can use these liners to tweak those colors. Happy to have such a variety of colors for such a cheap price

Would have preferred fewer pencils with better quality. Colors are bright! I thought the pencils were hard to get on and the wood didn't sharpen evenly. Wouldn't buy again.

I like having choices without having to purchase individual liners. I have darker skin so i would of liked to have the set of 6 all darker shades instead of the 12 with 6 very light and 6 med to dark. It's a waste of 6 lighter shades that i will not use. Overall; I'm completely satisfied with these lip liners. They go on smoothly and stay on for hours. I would purchase again.

These liners are perfect! Waterproof and very pigmented. I sometimes use them as lipstick and put a little lip gloss on top it looks great!

love the colors, they work really well, that said I use a lip primer before I use them. Very bold hues. Sharpen will with a LIP OR EYE sharpener.