Taffy Shop Create a Party (80oz) bag of Assorted Saltwater Taffy-Choose up to 5 Flavors of Gourmet Salt Water Taffy's (World's Best Taffy)

I grew up in areas famous for their salt water taffy, and it was always a favorite treat. This is very fine taffy, fresh and tasty. Flavorwise, well, you can't please everybody all the time. It gets 4 out of 5 for me. The Banana Dreams is my favorite. The Maple and Granny's Apple Pie are spot-on. The only problem with the Peanut Butter one is that I miss the straight shot of sugary peanut-butter filling that was in the ones I grew up with (and are still around in the Halloween black&orange ones but they're always a bit stale), but it is still peanut-buttery. But the Spicy Carrot Cake is all Spice, no Carrot, so it's a complete failure for me. Will definitely try other flavors in the future. Good stuff.

Not only is this a HUGE bag of taffy, it is absolutely delicious. I bought a bag of mixed taffy—there were a couple flavors I didn’t care for. I went back to reorder and saw that I could pick my own flavors! My second bag was absolutely perfect with my 5 favorites. The taffy is soft and chewy and very flavorful 😋

A little pricy but very good candy. Love the flavors that I picked

Delicious! The right softness and chewiness. Flavorful!! When I got my 5 custom flavor bag, they included samples for 5 other flavors! I ordered more after ordering my first batch- so so yum!

The taffy is delicious! I did get one flavor that was firm, not fresh like the rest, and they quickly replaced it. Great customer service, great product. I will be a repeat customer!

I'm a huge fan of salt water taffy and this is good stuff. I love that they have so many flavors and they are fun to try. The cinnamon flavor is one of my favorites and it has a spiciness that isn't present in a lot of other brands of cinnamon salt water taffy. All of the other flavors I've tried I've liked but especially Root beer float and passion fruit.

Other reviewers have already commented on the saltiness of the taffy. They are correct, but the saltiness is greatly reduced after the first couple of chews. I ordered some possibly disastrous choices: strawberry, passion fruit, mango, pear, and cinammon. The passion fruit was excellent; the strawberry was decent, though the flavour could have been more intense; same for the cinnamon; but the pear and mango weren't recognisable. I may try some other flavours, but, then again, I may not.

great taffy, great price. I love the option of being able to “mix your own bag”. I will buy again!