Three Twins Ice Cream, Madagascar Vanilla, 16 oz (Frozen)

Too bad Three Twins went out of business. They made the best commercially available organic ice cream and this was the best vanilla. At first their vanilla wasn't that good, but then the flavor profile improved... they used the Straus pre-manufactured base, but obviously started supplementing it with extra cream, eggs, and/or vanilla. It's hard to make good vanilla ice cream with vanilla extract, but they did it.

This is the best ice cream in the world. Not only is the vanilla good, but also the milk coffee and several other flavors. My only complaint would be that I eat the whole pint. I normally can only handle a few scoops of Bryers or Edys because they are too sweet. I don't know whats so different about this ice cream but it is sweet as well and I tend to eat the whole thing. Its just that good.

Tastes like home-made. Seriously I love this stuff.Unfortunately it's their only good flavor, but my god is it tasty.

I can't live without this one. Get more flavors, Whole Foods!

one of my rare guilty pleasures. I do not eat a lot of dairy and very rarely eat sweets. but if I am going to eat ice cream I want it to be this one.

So glad I came across this. Tasty but a lot of saturated fat, which is common for ice cream.

My husband loves this ice cream. Very rich.

This is quite literally the best ice cream I've ever tasted. I love vanilla ice cream, and nothing tastes quite like this. It's actually icy and creamy at the same time, it's smooth but you get a bit of a crunch from ice crystals. The vanilla flavor tastes incredibly pure and unadulterated.I'm a vanilla snob, I only like certain vanilla coffee creamers, ice cream and even extract. This is AMAZING ice cream. You won't be disappointed.